The Infamous /3gb Startup Switch

Standard

What is it ?

Windows Server 2003 includes support for a startup switch that lets you tune the allocation of use of memory and memory address space. Regardless of the amount of physical memory in your system, Windows uses a virtual address space of 4 GB, with 2 GB allocated to user-mode processes (for example, applications) and 2 GB allocated to kernel-mode processes (for example, the operating system and kernel-mode drivers). On systems that have 1 GB or more of physical memory, the startup switche can be used to allocate more memory to applications (3 GB) and less memory to the operating system (1 GB). This additional virtual address space helps reduce the amount of memory fragmentation.

How beneficial is it ?

You may have read many articles on this subject before. This discussion has been going on for many years now and at times has almost reached epic proportions due to the conflicting information available from Microsoft. Long story short is that by and large, you should NOT use the /3GB switch unless you meet specific criteria, please read the following article as it demystifies the whole theory. Or read the excerpt below.

http://blogs.technet.com/askperf/archive/2007/03/23/memory-management-demystifying-3gb.aspx

The /3GB option was intended as a short term solution to allow applications such as database servers to maintain more data in memory than a 2GB address space allowed. However, using the /3GB method to increase the user-mode memory space comes at a cost. If we have to allocate an additional 1GB of this address space to the user-mode space, then the System space is cut in half. Drivers, Heap, Paged & NonPaged Memory all have only half the resources to work with now. However, because of the way memory mapping works, cutting the kernel space in half does a lot more than just reducing the address space. Many of the structures within the kernel virtual memory space are cut back by far more than 50%.

For a process to access the full 3GB address space, the image file (application process) must have the IMAGE_FILE_LARGE_ADDRESS_AWARE flag set in the image header.

If the flag is not set in the image header, then the OS reserves the third gigabyte so that the application won’t see virtual addresses greater than 0x7FFFFFFF. You set this flag by specifying the linker flag /LARGEADDRESSAWARE when building the executable. This flag has no effect when running the application on a system with a 2-GB user address space. Therefore if you enable the /3GB switch, then applications that do not have this flag set can only use the standard 2GB of User mode memory, and the Kernel is still limited to the 1GB space – which means that 1GB of virtual memory is basically wasted !

All that is required to make it happen is a switch in the boot.ini file. The switch, /3GB, is placed
at the end of the line that executes the WinNT loading process.

Example:

[operating systems] multi(0)disk(0)rdisk(0)partition(2)\WINNT="Windows NT
Server Version 4.00" /3GB

Or you may add an additional line in your boot.ini as above to have the option to boot into either environment, with or without the switch.

What to keep in mind ?

This topic deals with the the virtual memory address space and has no relevance with the physical memory, it is however a limitation of a 32bit OS if you are running 64bit OS this not applicable. At the end of the day you must decide if your application is capable of handling this switch as an added benefit. Often times, if you are having to up the threshold of your OS handling of things and or things such as over-clocking your processor to keep up, one might worry about the logic behind it. Perhaps go for 64bit OS to begin with.

Can a RODC also be a DHCP ?

Standard

Sounds like a no-brainer, but there is catch. I installed DHCP role on my Server Core that I had previously set up as Read-only Domain Controller, using this command.

start /w ocsetup DHCPServerCore

And then I went ahead and set the service configuration to “auto” with this command,

sc config dhcpserver start= auto (note the space between the equal sign and auto)

And then finally when I tried to start the DHCP service with the following command, it failed with these errors.

net start dhcpserver

A system error has occured

System error 50 has occured

The request is not supported

So the catch was, that since RODC can’t write back to the AD to create the needed DHCP security groups i.e DHCP Administrators and DHCP Users, the service would fail.

After creating those domain local security groups on another Windows Server 2008 RWDC, the service does run successfully and you can manage the DHCP Server (that is running on Server Core) from another server using RSAT.

Is there a GUI to manage Server Core ?

Standard

Yes there is. Inevitable as it was, we the System Admins like to accomplish easy tasks from the tip of our fingers, and do things in a graphical click-ing environment. You might have heard of this utility, which came out few months back called ‘Server Core Configurator’ by Guy Teverovsky. I had been reading about the bugs and fixes at Guy’s site and hadn’t given a try. I have now downloaded a copy thats has been fixed up and fine tuned per the request of other readers and users who tried out this utility. I installed it on my Server Core copy and I haven’t been disappointed, it lets you do a lot of common tasks such as adding the machine to the domain, running DCPROMO on it, changing NIC settings, changing display and time zone etc. which would otherwise require you know the command line or registry edit.

While this utility will come in very handy (until Microsoft perhaps comes out of their own), remember its Microsoft’s attempt to offer a small footprint OS of Core features with the likes of Linux based DHCP, and DNS system such Infoblox, and they have tried to persuade the System Admins to learn the powerful capabilities of Cscripts, WMI and Netsh. This does take us the other way a little bit. But I sure am happy to see an option that allows to me do all those initial configuration tasks GUI-ily.

You be the judge and give it a try, download it from here,

http://blogs.microsoft.co.il/files/folders/guyt/entry68860.aspx

P.S You can only launch the application from the folder where it was installed, i.e change the directory to the C:\Program Files\Server Core Configurator where it installs by default.